When you're exploring new homes in Bixby, Oklahoma, you'll quickly discover that this charming city has more to offer than just beautiful neighborhoods and friendly communities. Who doesn’t love a list of the locals' favorite restaurants in their city? While it's easy to find the well-known, mainstream places to eat, the true treasures are often hidden in plain sight, tucked away in those off-the-beaten-path spots that only the locals know about. These are the hidden gems that residents of Bixby, Oklahoma, hold dear, places they might even hesitate to share with outsiders. But today, we're letting you in on the secret and revealing those coveted spots in Bixby that everyone is raving about! Whether you're new to the area or a long-time resident, these local favorites are sure to become your go-to dining destinations. At this point, we’re only revealing 5, so stay tuned for more to come.

Scotts Hamburgers

Scott’s Hamburgers has achieved “celebrity status” in Bixby and is the go-to spot for those looking to grab a bite before cheering on the high school football team to another victory. #GoSpartans! This family-owned spot is known for its mouth watering hamburgers and perfectly crispy onion rings, all made to order. Their burgers, featuring specially toasted buns and double patties, are a true delight, while the onion rings are a local favorite, with a secret to their golden, fried perfection. In addition to their famous burgers, Scott’s also offers a variety of options, including chicken, salads, and sandwiches for both lunch and dinner. For added fun, the restaurant features a game room complete with a pool table, video games, and a jukebox, making it a great place to relax and enjoy a meal.

Pizza Shoppe

A pizza shop with a Renaissance vibe? Is that even a thing? Yes, it sure is, and it’s located right here in Bixby, Oklahoma! If you live in Bixby and hear the word “pizza,” you immediately think of The Pizza Shoppe. This locally owned restaurant is known for its unique topping combinations on freshly baked crust. But what really sets this place apart is the PINK SAUCE! Yes, we’re using all caps because this stuff deserves to be shouted from the rooftops. We have no idea what’s in the PINK SAUCE, but after one dip, you’ll never want to eat pizza without it. And the best part? You can buy your very own bottle to take home. At Capital Homes, we love it so much we wrote a little beat about it:

Yo, it’s the PINK SAUCE, the flavor boss,
Drippin’ on your pizza, never takin’ a loss,
One dip, one taste, and you’re hooked for life,
Can’t imagine a slice without that pink delight.

Mystery in a bottle, but it’s all you need,
From Bixby to your home, it’s the sauce you’ll feed,
Shout it from the rooftops, spread the word loud,
The PINK SAUCE is king, and it’s wearin’ the crown!

Johnson's Stepping Stone

If you're craving the comforting warmth of a home-cooked meal that takes you back to the days when grandma would spend hours in the kitchen, Johnson's Stepping Stone is the spot you've been looking for. Imagine sitting down to a plate of golden, crispy chicken fried steak drenched in rich, savory gravy, with a heaping side of buttery mashed potatoes, or a thick slice of perfectly seasoned homemade meatloaf that practically melts in your mouth. It's the kind of place where every bite feels like a hug, and you leave with both a satisfied heart and a box of homemade pie to savor later. Trust me, adding an extra notch to your belt after a visit here is all part of the charm.

Lazy Fisherman

Since 1995, The Lazy Fisherman in Bixby, Oklahoma has been delighting diners with its Southern-style seafood at unbeatable prices. Their signature dish, perfectly fried catfish, comes with sides like homemade brown beans, coleslaw, French fries, and delicious hush puppies. For those feeling adventurous, the frog legs and iconic fried green tomatoes are must-tries.

If you're in the mood for something more familiar, The Lazy Fisherman also offers shrimp, hamburgers, onion rings, and chicken fried steak. Don’t forget to save room for dessert—whether it’s a slice of homemade coconut cream or German chocolate pie, or an individually fried crescent pie filled with apple, cherry, apricot, pineapple, or peach. With consistently delicious food and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, The Lazy Fisherman is a beloved spot for both locals and visitors in Bixby.

The Real Taco

No explanation needed, only one word required….Street Tacos. Run, don’t walk.

BONUS!!!

Le’s Gas Station

Do not let the curb appeal deter you from venturing inside to meet the sweetest owners and their incredible Vietnamese Coffee! One sip and you’ll never drive by again without stopping. We promise, this will not let you down. Also, we’ve heard the sandwiches are to die for but have yet to try them ourselves. 

Doc's Country Mart

We’re all guilty of stopping into the local Reasors to grab a little Sushi. Now, it’s never as good as our favorite spots but it fits the need. When you grab a roll at Docs, you’ll be pleasantly surprised. Honestly, don’t trust our word for it, stop in and become a believer yourself.

Pepper Express

This little gem is located downtown and if you blink you could miss it. The portions are incredible and offer great flavor if you're craving some beef lo mein or fried rice.